Apathy's first appearance was in Episode XCV where he took over a conversation after Jack dismissed a Puffball after Apathy notices Ashi's disappearance and was pleased with it. However, when Jack was going to save her, Apathy later got annoyed by it.
- "Well then, maybe you'll talk to me!"
- "Look, why do you always have to get involved? She chose her way, and now she has to live with the consequences.”
- "(Smirking) She's gone.”
- "Ok, well that's that. Let's get out of here."
- "(Sighing) You're going to save her life, aren't you?”